Controversial topics such as this in literature are educational and hopefully insightful. Learning from the past should be helpful in making just decisions for a better future for all stakeholders. (Women, men politicians, churches etc.)
I am pleased to see that most responders agree that controversial subjects should be explored through literature. Topics like these are great for discussion among other readers. Jodi Picoult is very well received with most of her books bringing a controversial topic into the story.
Well said Anke_V I totally agree and am encouraged that many others feel the same way!!
Knowledge is powerâŚa familiar refrain. So true. This is how we learn, explore, discuss, research and importantly come to our own conclusions. It is not about opinionâŚit is about reality. This story is about Mimiâs reality. Allowing us to follow her thoughts and actions contribute to our own development. We need to be exposed to controversial topics to help us develop our own critical thinking skillsâŚ.which I think are lacking in many. Reactions to these topics are fueled by misinformation, opinion and emotion.
I totally agree with you. Your comments are well stated.
Good literature reflects the culture of various times in history and should reflect all sides of an issue but should not be taken as historical fact (I have two degrees in history and I am greatly bothered by those who read historical fiction and believe it to be far more factual than many books are). Yet, a well-written character can invoke empathy amongst readers and show a side that mirrors real-life (and not mere propaganda) which could very well lead someone to look deeper into a topic and expand their way of thinking. One can certainly learn about societyâs mores and how things have changed (for the better, hopefully) and often good fiction can shine a light on those topicsâusually involving womenâthat are given short shrift in history books. I once had a woman tell me (with her nose in the air) that she only read âtrueâ books that she could learn from; I gently said she can learn from any book, that sometimes empathy is more educational than facts.
Excellent points, Carol Ann. Many years ago I taught a graduate course about primary sources. Two keys were that p.s. are biased and reflect the views of the creator be it an author, photographer, painter, reporter, etc. For example, any photo I take is from my viewpoint, using my eye of what I choose to include in the image.
The other key was that history is (usually) written/told/presented by the victorious, which infers bias.
Your reminders are essential to hold within my mind when reading historical fiction and nonfiction. Thank you for your post!