If Tom had not left, do you believe Elena still would have found her way to becoming her "true artistic self"? Why or why not?

If Tom had not left, do you believe Elena still would have found her way to becoming her “true artistic self”? Why or why not?

No, I think Elena needed the alone time to be able to hone in on her true self. She needed to be able to find herself again without Tom and the kids. She did just that which made her a better partner and mother in the end.

Likely not as Elena would have been caught in the expectations of her role. Changing the bedroom into an art studio was her turning point; her pre-Reset. I don’t think she would have done this had Tom still lived at home. She would have been absorbed by being the “older woman.”

1 Like

No. Elena just like Tom needed some space. As a mother she didn’t have time to this when her children were young and with Tom’s character she became a lawyer’s wife and adjusted her life accordingly. With Tom gone Elena could focus on herself and what she needed.

I doubt she would. In her own words she yhought her reset would continue the llife she had been leading as a wife and mother, and possibly she would have had one or more children. She was very upset by Tom’s decision to move out and maybe “sow some wild oats,” The end result was that she unleashed her artistic capabilities and a new Elena emrged.

Agree with your assessment.

1 Like

I do not think she would have. She was very busy in her own world as a wife and mother.

I agree when Tom left, it gave Elena the motivation and freedom to pursue her art talent. If he had stayed home, she would have continued her role as wife and mother.

I am the outlier on this question. I think Elena might eventually have rediscovered her “true artistic self”. After spending many years absorbed in her roles as a wife and mother, she may have returned to artistic expression once her children left home. It is not unusual for a parent to revive old interests or discover new ones once they have an “empty nest”.

1 Like

Perhaps, but I think it unlikely. She would’ve been busy in her role as a wife, and once she reset, would have been part of Tom’s plans feather than her own. Maybe as she aged for the second time, her artistic life would have become important again.

Deep down in my hearts of hearts, I like to think she would have. Especially when her children were out of the house. I believe she had it in her and that Tom only dampened it.

I agree with the other commenters that she might never have fully realized her artistic identity had Tom not left. His betrayal of their vows, and the pain and loss it caused, seems to have propelled her toward a degree of self-discovery she may not otherwise have achieved. Moreover, her anxiety about being judged for pursuing a relationship with a “younger man” would likely have inhibited her further, preventing her from embracing and expressing the artist within.

No, I think it would not have changed the dynamics enough for her to change her behavior and pursue her art. She would have been worrying about what people thought with the “younger” man and how she would handle the issues with their age difference.

I don’t think that she would have or at least not for a very long time. She had tied too much of her identity to him, and being forced a bit to reconsider what else life could be came from that hurt.

No - I think they would have remained in their bubble and she would never have explored anything new.

I think she pretty much tells us in the story that without Tom’s actions she would have reset, but expected to keep on living the life she was living. To me this means she would not have explored her art. I think this is one of the parts of the book that I enjoy. As it demonstrates “the law of unintended circumstances”. Tom would also never have expected her to pursue her own passions - he was too wrapped up in his own. It added a great deal to the depth of the story.

Tom leaving was exactly what Elena needed to finally put her interests first and grow as a person. Tom was a selfish jerk. It makes me wonder what their lives would have been like when he reset again and she still had 18 months to go. Would she have stayed?

No, I do not. Especially because she with Tom anout how she was originally thinking another baby and dog would be nice. It wasn’t until Tom left that she was able to really just stop and think about what she wanted for herself.

I don’t think Elena would have become the artist she became if ‘Tom had not left. Him leaving really was a shock to her and I don’t think she would have had the time or motivation to get back to her artistic roots. She would have still been the dutiful wife and mother to Tom and kids.